Arizona Federal Court Denies Attempt to Dismiss Firefighter’s First Amendment Retaliation Case

By Mitchell Riese

A recent decision from U.S. l District Court in Arizona denied the City of Prescott, Arizona’s attempt to dismiss a lawsuit by a former firefighter, who alleged that he had been coerced into retiring by being threatened with criminal charges for having traded shifts. In  Vicente v. City of Prescott, AZ, 33 IER Cases 1306 (D. Ariz. 2012), Vicente, who had been a firefighter for almost 20 years and a Captain for 10, was vice president of the firefighters union. In that role, he advocated on behalf of two union members who claimed that they were being harassed by certain managers. Not long after Vicente assisted the members in filing formal complaints, he was called into a meeting and told that he had engaged in criminal conduct by trading shifts or obtaining substitutes for shifts with other firefighters. He was told that the situation was serious and that his job could not be saved. Vicente was told that his only option was to retire. Vicente claimed that he was told that he had to cease all union activity because that was the reason why they were all there.

[Read more…]

A Facebook “Thumbs-Up” Could be a Thumbs Down for your First Amendment Rights

By Cynthia McNabb

In the ever-evolving legal environment regarding use of social media in and outside the workplace, a new case before the 4th Circuit is getting quite a bit of attention.  In Bland v. Roberts, a deputy sheriff (along with five others) went on his Facebook page and, like millions of others every day, clicked the “like” button on a page he was viewing.  The page happened to be a political page for a candidate running against his boss, the Sheriff of Hampton, VA.  Once his boss was re-elected, Deputy Carter, along with Bland, et. all were terminated.  The employer alleged that the employees were terminated for poor work performance and their support of the opposing candidate had disrupted the workplace. [Read more…]

Ninth Circuit Reaffirms First Amendment Right of Public Employees to be Free of Retaliation

By Mitchell Riese

The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals recently clarified the rights that public employees have to not be retaliated against by a supervisor for testifying in a deposition in the context of a civil rights lawsuit. In the case of Karl v. City of Mountlake  Terrace, Martha Karl  filed suit against the City of Mountlake Terrace and Assistant Chief of Police Pete Caw.  Karl was the Confidential Administrative Assistant to the Chief of Police. In 2008, she was subpoenaed to give deposition testimony in a federal civil rights lawsuit filed by former department Sgt. [Read more…]